Mel's Shopping Diary
Twilight of the Books
January 09, 2008I was reading the New Yorker the other day and read this article about the “Twilight of Books” and how because of television, less and less people are reading, and this is of course a bad thing, not just for writers like myself
but for society and democracy as a whole. Anyway, apparently if you read the news, you are more likely to remember differing opinions and come to your own independent conclusion whereas if you merely watch the news, all information just kind of seeps out of your brain and leaves you a zombie.
Now I am not anti-TV at all. There are three very large flat-screen TVs in my home and my brother bought my dad a new 50-inch 1080-res flatscreen for Christmas, which overjoyed my dad so much that he declared that “only one of his children loves him.” Ha! So, you know I love me some television--it’s in my blood. And my husband’s parents are so pro-TV that they get really annoyed when any of their children meekly suggests that maybe watching TV is not good for their kids. (Mike and I are wrestling with this right now: unfortunately, Mattie LOVES the TV. We put Sesame Street on when she wakes up because it means we get to sleep in a little longer. But now our electronic babysitter is biting us in the ass. Whenever Mattie sees any of the TVs in our home, she immediately picks up the remote and demands to see “Melmo!")
But you know--the pleasures of watching and the pleasures of reading are such different things. I LOVE books, in such a personal, intimate way, whereas I merely enjoy television. I don’t love the shows. They don’t inspire that kind of feeling, that kind of passion. The article had a great quote from Proust that I’m going to quote now because I love it so much:
To read “is to receive a communication with another way of thinking, all the while remaining alone, that is, while continuing to enjoy the intellectual power that one has in solitude and that conversation dissipates immediately.”
I love that--"intellectual power that conversation DISSIPATES immediately.” I mean, in person, I am not even a fourth as articulate as I am in print. Mostly I giggle and smile a lot and act a bit goofy. My husband, also, is very quiet in person. But he’s pretty much the smartest guy I know. (Hey girls: marry the funniest and the smartest guy you know NOT the cutest. The cute ones are usually pretty dumb. I mean: I thought Zac Efron was gorgeous but now he just looks kind of dim-witted to me. Especially wearing his long bangs in a ponytail and drinking a Jamba like he was in Us Weekly. Although you know, come to think of it, if you saw me schlepping out of the Jamba with a large frosty drink wearing my Uggs and my hair in a ponytail and my Marc Jacobs aviators, you’d probably think I was stoopit too. So you know, we can’t judge. Anyway, If you’re lucky you’ll get smart and cute and funny. And any guy can be cute. You don’t need conventionally cute. I think ugly and interesting and funny is so much better. My friends were always in despair of my taste. They thought the guys I liked were so ugly. Although I did marry a good-looking dude. Well, like I said, sometimes you get lucky.)
Anyway, when I told Mike about this article, he brought up a lot of points about how maybe TV-watching is not the end of the world and no one can really predict how things will go and it’s never as bad as it seems. Mike tends to always question things he reads with a healthy skepticism, while I slavishly believe everything I read. He always reminds me of this, as in, “Why do you believe everything you read in magazines when you used to WRITE for them and you KNOW how manipulative and fake all the stories are.”
It’s true. I would put together BEST HAIR PRODUCT pages and on the instruction of my editor, put in a cheapo one and an expensive advertiser one, because that was the mag’s policy. And yet, whenever I flip through the beauty pages, I still rip out their BEST HAIR PRODUCT pages and go buy what they recommend. Even if I know how they chose it. I can’t help myself. Also, there are a lot of very SERIOUS beauty editors out there--who really test the products and decide why something is worth writing about. Unfortunately, I wasn’t one of them. I just loved all the free loot!
Well. Back to the quote and reading. What I liked about that quote is that it also tells us WHY it is that books inspire so much passion--or in the case of bad reviews and disgruntled readers--so much hatred and anger. Because it is a “COMMUNICATION with ANOTHER way of thinking.” So if you disagree with the point-of-view of a novel or a book, you virulently HATE it. Whereas if you agree with it, you find an affection for it that is very deep.
Anyway, I just thought that was a really interesting article, because it really summed up why reading is important and how reading doesn’t just spark the imagination but INSPIRES people to better themselves and have better lives. It simply amazes me that I have the life that I have now. Not because my parents didn’t expect it--we were always expected to succeed--but because I have the life that I alone wanted and dreamed of--the life of a writer.
One thing that I always feel gratified by is the amount of mail I get from teens who say they never liked to read before, until they found my books. Reading is a PLEASURE. I got hooked on reading because of popular authors and their racy, steamy books...like Judith Krantz’s “I’ll Take Manhattan!” (I still remember the scene where the heroine is tapped down by the airport police going through the metal detector and she snaps her black underwear at them. It just stuck in my mind because I grew up in a very conservative environment and the black underwear thing seemed so deliciously racy and naughty and spelled adult freedom. When I was out of the house and in college the first thing I did was buy black underwear. Does it have the same resonance now? With the porn-star t-shirts and thongs for seven-year-olds?)
Back to the Blue Bloods and the Ashleys! And sorry if people thought the sneak-peek was cruel. It wasn’t meant to be!
xoxo
Mel
On January 9, 2008 at 7:16 pm, Valeriya had this to say:
I COMPETELY agree! I love to read, and for people my age (or even in my generation) its wierd. My friends read alot too, and we love reading. That just shows that even with in the highschool comunity, there are students who understand that necessity and interest of reading. Personally, I’ve never really liked watching tv (unless i couldn’t fall asleep at night, television happens to be very good at boring a person enough to make them fall asleep) and have always, as long as i can remember, prefered reading. Books bring you to a different place, and allow you to use your imagination. TV, on the other hand, forces you to see something as how ANOTHER PERSON (namely the director) imagines it to be. That’s also why books that are turned into movies bother some people, the director just pictures things differently than you do. People with inteligence like to read, people who watch too much TV instead of reading, have all of their intelligence burned away by force of pixels.
On January 11, 2008 at 8:15 am, clarissa had this to say:
Wow, ya i can totally relate. I love reading, dont get me wrouge i’m all for TV, but i think the main problem is kids are forced to read as assignments. I personally dont like being told what to read, and when it come to assigned books they can be pretty boring. I think most kids think all books are that way, or just have trouble reading and it can be very agitating. I Love you books along w/ the entire Twilight series( You should read them if you havent they are AMAZING)
On January 11, 2008 at 11:59 pm, yuki had this to say:
that sounds so intresting and weird i read the entire thing
On January 13, 2008 at 9:22 am, Lianne had this to say:
I love TV. Some shows I love just as much as I love my favorite books. Like, I would so choose just about any book over Project Runway or something but I couldn’t do the same thing for the X-Files or Avatar. If it has a good plot and good characters then I definitely feel pretty passionate about it no matter what the medium.
On January 21, 2008 at 3:10 pm, Kat had this to say:
I absolutely love to read and was voted bookworm in my grade (sorta cruel but whatever). I would always always always choose books over tv but just as Lianne says some shows have great plots and i cant miss them (for example: Avatar, I love this show tooooo!!)
On January 21, 2008 at 6:30 pm, K had this to say:
I agree,
beside a tv show lasts for 1/2h to 1h and if you want to watch it again you have to pay like sixty bucks for a whole season. But books, you get a lifetime of enjoyment for about a quarter of the price.
Not that I’m a cheapo or anything, just putting the stats out their!
On January 21, 2008 at 6:31 pm, k had this to say:
*there
whoopsie!
On January 28, 2008 at 6:59 pm, Allyson had this to say:
I love to read and watch tv. Sometimes tv wins, but I try not to let that happen. My sister on the other hand can finsh 20 thick books. Its true what they say reading makes you smarter cause I have and my sis has all honors in high school and she makes straight A’s.
On February 28, 2008 at 1:22 pm, Kayla had this to say:
I agree!!!!!!
On February 28, 2008 at 2:11 pm, Emma had this to say:
I absolutly luv books, I can live without them. I mean wut am I supposed to do in math class if I don’t have a book with me, pay attention? (surprisingly enough I get A’s in that class, our teacher sucks, I just know how to read a text book). I mean some movies are amazing and I jsut fall absoulutly in love with them, but I find tv shows pointless (they are too short), actually I really just don’t like tv at all, it rules all aspects of this generation. At least at school a few other girls luv to read like me, and we have like an unofficial book club because we will read books, recommened them to each other, and then discuss them in the hallways on the way to class. GO BOOKS!!!
On January 9, 2008 at 4:34 pm, Li vy had this to say:
I know exactly what you mean. If given a choice between 100 of my favorite TV shows and movies or 100 of my favorite books. I would choose books over shows and movies any day. Books are a place where you can leave behind the world and enter a new one where you can have fun and use your imagination to its full advantage. Books by far are the best inspiration for anyone. Whether some think that is true or not who cares. Books are our friends not our enemies.